The Myth of Overqualified Candidates: Rethink Experience in Hiring

In today's hiring landscape, many organizations say they want top talent. They claim to be seeking experienced, strategic talent that's ready to lead. But when that candidate shows up with a strong resume and leadership experience, hiring managers often utter a familiar word: overqualified.

It may even sound like a compliment at first, but let's be honest—it's usually just a rejection in disguise. And more importantly, it's a signal that we're still operating with outdated notions about what makes someone the "right fit".

It's past time we dig into this.

Overqualified Candidates Aren't a Thing (Bias is though)

When hiring managers or recruiters label someone "overqualified", they're often responding to discomfort and unknowns—not data. They may assume the candidate will:

• Be too expensive

• Get bored quickly

• Leave as soon as something "better" comes along

• Undermine leadership or disrupt team culture

But none of these assumptions are tied to actual conversations with the candidate. They're all just guesses. And those guesses are shaped by bias, not facts

What's worse is that those assumptions often push out people with marginalized identities who've had to build untraditional, nonlinear careers. Founders, career changers, caregivers, survivors—many of these folks bring exactly the kind of grit and perspective that forward-thinking organizations say they want.

So if we're serious about inclusive hiring, we have to retire the myth of the "overqualified" candidate.

Myth vs. Fact: Rethinking the Overqualified Label

Myth	Fact
"Overqualified" candidates won't stick around.	Job stability is never guaranteed—plenty of underqualified hires leave quickly too. Motivation and fit matter more than assumptions about someone's career stage.
They'll want too much money.	First—pay people what's fair and this will never be an issue. Secondly—many candidates are flexible about compensation when they believe in the mission and team. You won't know until you ask.
They'll be bored or hard to manage.	Experienced professionals often thrive in new contexts. This is especially true when they are respected and engaged. Work doesn't have to be astronomically challenging for it to be interesting and aligned.
They'll outshine or intimidate others.	Strong teams aren't threatened by excellence—they're built around it. The goal isn't comfort, it's growth.

How to Shift Your Hiring Mindset

If you're trying to build a stronger, more inclusive team, here are three shifts to consider:

1. Start with a conversation, not a conclusion

Ask candidates about their motivations, goals, and how they see themselves contributing. Don't let fear or "too much experience" close the door before you even open it.

2. Value lived experience as much as linear experience.

Some of the best leaders didn't climb the ladder. They, instead, built something from scratch, survived life-altering challenges, or navigated multiple roles at once. That's a real, transferable skill.

3. Redefine what "fit" means

Instead of hiring for familiarity or comfort, hire for contribution. Who can stretch the team, bring new insight, and help you grow?

The Bottom Line

Dismissing someone as "overqualified" is often just another way of saying, "We don't know how to value your experience." And that's a loss—not for the candidate, but for the organization.

So next time you meet a candidate who seems too skilled, too seasoned, too everything—pause. Ask better questions. Have a real, human-to-human conversation. Expand your thinking.

Because in a world that needs courageous, capable, and creative leaders more than ever, we can't afford to keep overlooking the ones right in front of us.

---

Not sure how to get started? Let's connect! Schedule a free consultation with our team at Imagine Impact. We can help you navigate your next search with intention + all the right questions!

Schedule a Free Consultation